Egypt: Al Subh Solar Power, Sunrise Energy and Rising Sun Energy-01

Date Filed
17 Mar 2024
Status
Open
Phase
Dispute Resolution (DR)
Country
Egypt, Arab Republic of

Case Tracker

Eligibility
March 17, 2024-May 29, 2024
Eligibility
Assessment
May 30, 2024-November 12, 2024
Assessment
Dispute Resolution
Dispute Resolution
Status as of November 12, 2024
Compliance
CURRENT Status
Mediation (DISPUTE RESOLUTION)
Status as of November 12, 2024

Complaint Overview

Complainant

Three community members from the Benban village

Concerns

Non-renewal of employment contracts, unfavorable working conditions, perceptions of threats and reprisals
 

Cross-Cutting Issues
Labor

Project Information

Region
Africa
Institution
IFC/MIGA
Name & Number
IFC: #39729, #39995, #39997 - MIGA: #14080, #14059, #14043
Company
Al Subh Solar Power S.A.E., Sunrise Energy S.A.E., and Rising Sun Energy S.A.E.
Sector
Infrastructure
Department
Infrastructure

Synopsis

Project Overview

Al Subh Solar Power S.A.E, Sunrise Energy S.A.E, and Rising Sun Energy S.A.E are Special Purpose Vehicles for the development, construction, operation, and maintenance of solar photovoltaic (PV) power plants with a capacity of 50MW each, located within the Benban Solar Park. Benban Solar Park is a 36 sq km plot composed of 32 operational power plants that are operated by different companies, near the village of Benban in Egypt. All project developers have formed the Benban Solar Developers Association (BSDA) to manage the entirety of the Solar Park.

IFC Projects: In July 2017, the IFC Board approved solar energy projects in Egypt, each consisting of a 50 MW greenfield solar PV plant under Round 2 of Egypt's feed-in-tariff (FiT) scheme for solar and wind energy. The projects were developed by Special Purpose Vehicles (SPVs) owned by a joint venture (JV) led by Acciona Energía Global and ENARA Bahrain SPV WLL. The JV partners, which include Acciona and ENARA Bahrain, each hold a 50% stake in the SPVs. The projects were financed with a total cost of around US$64 million per plant, with IFC providing US$15.3 million in loans and syndications of US$37.5 million per project. The remaining financing came from equity. All projects achieved Commercial Operation Date (COD) in March 2019.

MIGA Projects: In 2018, MIGA issued guarantees of $14.49 million each to Acciona Energía Global and ENARA Bahrain SPV WLL for their investments in three solar projects: Rising Sun Energy S.A.E., Sunrise Energy S.A.E., and Al Subh Solar Power S.A.E. The guarantees cover risks related to Transfer Restrictions, Expropriation, War and Civil Disturbance, and Breach of Contract, with a 15-year duration. These projects are also part of Egypt’s Round 2 feed-in-tariff program.

Complaint

In March 2024, CAO received a complaint submitted by three individuals from Benban village regarding their employment by Securitas Egypt in the Benban Solar Park in Aswan, Egypt. One individual was delegated to represent all three complainants. The complaint raised concerns about non-renewal of employment contracts, unfavorable working conditions, and perceptions of threats and reprisals.

Action

In May 2024, CAO found the complaint eligible and began its assessment. caoDuring CAO’s assessment, the parties agreed to participate in a dispute resolution process.  In accordance with the CAO policy, the complaint has been transferred to CAO's Dispute Resolution function.

The Assessment Report is available in English and Arabic. 

Status

The case is in dispute resolution. 

Status as of November 28, 2024. 

Case Documents

  • Assessment

    Assessment Report
    Assessment Report
    Nov 12, 2024
    English
    Assessment Report
    Assessment Report
    Nov 12, 2024
    Arabic
    Assessment Report
  • Mailchimp Survey

     

    We Value Your Feedback

    Thank you for visiting CAO’s new website. Help us improve your experience by taking our short survey.

    Give Feedback No thanks